Alan's list: (would you please let Jenny know what you are getting him so she doesn't also buy him the same thing)
Quiddler (card game)
behind-the-head earmuffs like
these
John Grisham novels: The Whistler, Rogue Lawyer, or Gray Mountain
Any of the following church books: By the Hand of Mormon, by Terryl Givens
Power to Become, by Elder Bednar
Act in Doctrine, by Elder Bednar
Increase in Learning, by Elder Bednar
Beholding the Tree of Life, by Bradley Kramer
The Book of Mormon Made Harder, by James Faulconer
Here is a link to Jenny's Amazon wish list. Sorry, I have been storing ideas for my kids on my wish list, but there are a few things there that I would like, too. These include some young adult novels: the Penderwicks series (4 books for a total of $22 on Amazon), the Calpurnia Tate books (there are 2 in the series), the Princess Bride (book, not the movie), or a couple of cookbooks by the Six Sisters Stuff.
Both of us also love gift cards: Zupas, Olive Garden, Cafe Rio, Chilis, or Kneaders. Gift cards are not a cop-out.